top of page

Gas Fireplaces in Montreal: Natural Gas or Propane, How to Choose?

Daniel Rochon
Aug 30
3 min read

Updated: Oct 26

The choice between a natural gas and propane fireplace depends primarily on the availability of the network in your street and your installation requirements .


Natural gas

  • Availability: Requires a direct connection to the city's underground network (available mainly in urban or dense suburban areas).

  • Operation: Continuous continuous supply; you never risk running out of fuel.

  • Practical: Zero tank or delivery management, the monthly bill adjusts according to consumption.

  • Cost of use: Generally more economical to use than propane if the network is already present near the home.


Propane

  • Availability: Ideal in rural areas or areas not served by mains gas.

  • Operation: Stored in an outdoor tank or bottles connected to the house.

  • Autonomy: Requires planning for refills or renting/buying a propane cylinder from a specialized supplier.

  • Power: Offers excellent energy value per unit, but tank installation involves more logistics and upfront costs.


Gas fireplace with Dreamcast mantel from stauv.com

Decision Criteria

  1. Check your street address: First, confirm with your local supplier whether the natural gas line runs directly past your house. If not, propane becomes the obvious option.

  2. Installation: Both types of devices require certified installation that complies with current standards (such as RBQ licenses in Quebec).

  3. Conversion: Most modern gas fireplaces can operate on both fuels, but require a specific conversion kit (suitable injectors) installed by a professional.


-The right choice is evident in your address, your land, your wall.

-The most reliable decision-making process begins with what is already there.

In practice, what makes a gas fireplace installation successful isn't general arguments, but the actual compatibility between the chosen energy source and your home. A street connection, a plot of land too small for a gas tank, an exterior wall requiring a specific venting method, these details determine the outcome even before the fireplace arrives at your door.


Here are 2 figures that show why the choice between natural gas and propane directly influences feasibility, compliance, and the final cost.

Numerical statistics

What this demonstrates concretely on the ground

Clickable source

Énergir distributes approximately 97% of the natural gas consumed in Quebec, with a network of about 11,000 km and just over 211,000 customers.

If your area is not within the service zone, natural gas will be excluded from the project, and propane will become the realistic option; this is not a preference.

For a 420 lb tank, Superior Propane lists estimated installation fees of $299 and annual rental fees of $149.

Propane adds fixed costs that are visible from the outset, even before factoring in removal, connection, and finishing work.

The home visit transforms your project into a solid decision

A home technical assessment allows you to validate everything that really matters: the location, possible evacuation, access to energy, the constraints of your house, the finishing work to be planned, and it is also the time to ask for a detailed budget, item by item, to know exactly what you are paying for.

When this step is done correctly, you are no longer buying a gas fireplace, you are confirming a complete project, compliant, and adapted to your home.


You now have the right reference points to choose between natural gas and propane

A short home visit allows us to validate these points, contact us: info@stauv.com


FAQ


- What is the difference between a natural gas and propane fireplace?

The main difference between a natural gas fireplace and a propane fireplace lies in their method of supply : natural gas arrives through a continuous underground pipeline, while propane is stored in a tank or cylinder outside the house.


- How much does a gas fireplace cost?

Entry-level: 6,000 to 8,500 for a basic traditional model.

High-end or architectural: 8,000 to 30,000+ for wide linear fireplaces, built-in or visible on several sides.


Does a gas fireplace require a chimney?

Yes, the majority of modern gas fireplaces use a sealed exhaust pipe that exits directly through an exterior wall or through the roof.


- Which gas fireplace should I choose for a modern living room?

For a modern living room, opt for a frameless linear or vertical gas fireplace, offering a clean and panoramic view of the flames.


- Is a gas fireplace more economical than a wood-burning fireplace?

Wood-burning fireplaces are generally cheaper in terms of fuel, but gas fireplaces offer better efficiency and require less effort.


- Can an existing wood-burning fireplace be converted into a gas fireplace?

Yes, it is entirely possible to convert an existing wood-burning fireplace into a gas fireplace using a built-in (or insert) gas fireplace, however an inspection of the existing fireplace is necessary to properly assess its conformity before any work is carried out.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page